I typically assume that he's very attentive and has a great personality. Something I've noticed with good looking guys is that often times talking to them is like talking to a brick wall. They never pay attention and they barely ever pretend to. A lot of times they tend to just get by on their looks because they know that girls will be more likely to take a lot more crap from them since they look good.
This is why I almost rarely ever date an 8/10. DiCaprio is about as good looking as you can get without some fatal personality flaw in my experience (well.. with the exception of Johnny Depp of course... he's an angel). And if you can score a hot guy that used to be fat? You're a winner.
Average guys and overweight guys on the other hand can be great catches because they know what they have and they're more afraid to lose her. If you're a 6 dating a 9 you're not gonna screw it up by being a jerk to her. You're going to pay attention to her, be nice to her, and generally be the best boyfriend that you can be (assuming that she has a good personality as well).
That's how I feel about the whole situation anyway
C and E. This just happened to me today with a girl I know from my past. I thought firstly... Wow she doesn't have very high standards... Must realize how many great good looking guys she could get... But then he brought her ovesome food and he seemed very sweet and good to her. Seemed like he had a good personality. So I reminded myself that looks aren't everything. I also noticed when two attractive people get together, it doesn't usually work out for various frustrating reasons.
I don't think anything. He could have any manner of great qualities to make her fall for him. Whatever attracts her. Be it money, integrity, smarts, kindness, diligence, even some random skill she admires. It can be virtually anything that makes him appear powerful. Power attracts women first and foremost. So being surprised by this kind of couple is ridiculous.
I myself fell for a really ugly guy because he was insanely smart. I could do nothing but talk to him for the whole day and I'd still crave his company at the end of it. He also had this cocky and childish personality. I really liked him...
This is awkward, because I feel like I should pick E, but then that's still assuming she picked him on his looks, just that her definition of hot is different from mine. (ie, society tends to like blondes, maybe she has a thing for black hair?) I don't know. I don't know why people fall in love.
If I see a hot woman with an average guy I assume they've know each other for a while, she like his personality or she wants something from him. Not all at once I've seen different couple who fit those assumptions. Rarely is it because they're in love but eh whatever.
Don't really think anything. I know we have different taste in men, so...But I do notice when a really hot guy is with a not-so-good looking girl. I like to think he sees past her looks which is admirable.:)