A little baggy and sagging in a good thing but no more than the waist band of his boxers/underwear. It is the biggest turn off to see the guy's pants sag past their cheeks and then they belt them to stay there.
So I would say a tight pant is better... but skinny pants (you only said tight not skinny I know) either look good or bad. If he has extra weight on him then it makes him look 20 lbs heavier especially if he wears colored ones but if he is really skinny wearing skinny pants, it looks disgusting like he has stage IV cancer or another horrible disease.
not everyone can pull off tight pants- sometimes it looks ridiculous. but being able to see a guy's underwear and having his pants falling off? absurd, stupid, it looks like you don't know how to wear clothes. so A.
I can't stand guys who wear baggy pants, seriously, how hard is it to keep your pants up? It's one of my pet peeves. Tight pants are OK but I honestly don't care what pants a guy wears as long as they're not baggy.
Well if they are really baggy or TOO tight then it's a turn off, seeing the shape of his butt isn't bad at all! lol Seeing too much underwear is like ughh. It does depend on his shape and style though. Guys can pull off certain ones so...
In your link, I liked the normal jeans, and the skinny jeans didn't look that bad. Although that could have been the model.
This is weird, but I sort of like that guys clothes is getting tighter. We girls have been showing off the curvature of our butts for forever, why shouldn't they? Maybe if we all suffer in too tight jeans together we'll all realize that sweatpants are the way to go. ;)