Based on how I look with minimal make-up and how much make-up I actually need. Most women wear make-up in public, so it would be unfair to compare my clean face with their fully made up faces. It's really difficult to judge your attractiveness nowadays. But I think I'm pretty attractive. Based on the fact that I never wear foundation since my face is clear and even, and only my eyes need a bit of enhancing. I know it sounds smug, but I really don't see many women who don't have acne or scars on their faces.
I try not to judge myself which is probably why I love my sweats and messy hair cause I know I look like crap I'm not trying can't feel shitty if you really don't care enough to try. But when I do. I judge myself on how dark my stupid eyes are or how that my stomach jiggles just a little to much but mostly I judge myself by the way my clothes fit. I worked out hardcore for a few months and I gained a lot muscle and my jeans didn't fit right totally felt like crap even though I was improving and you could see it I was leaner I just didn't lose weight as much as gained muscle and I hated myself for it
i judge my looks by my face and if my hair looks pretty and volumous or lank and rubbish, I think the best I look in makeup is the best I can ever look and without makeup depends on if I have a spot or not lol. I already have a naturally slim curvy body so I'm never worried about that
I know without makeup, I'm a 3/4. With makeup, I'm still around a 4 >.<
I'm average either way, so it's not as though I'm a 2 without makeup and all of a sudden calling myself an 8 with.
But different situations call for different judgments. If I'm going to a party, I'm aiming to look good with makeup while I'm all dressed up. If I'm hanging around my apt, I'm aiming to look good while being laid back.