I prefer choice A and B only. Anything else just makes the person look like they are wearing a really bad disguise. If a woman is wearing too much make-up, I don't care what she is saying to me...I will just stare at her and think over and over in my head...I want to wash this sh*t off your face...I want to wash this sh*t off your face...I want to wa.. ahh you get the idea. Cosmetics are like Vodka and promises to Jesus to stop doing something bad if your not pregnant.. Use sparingly. - j
Too much is never good, so not C or D. A and B are both fine, but I guess if I absolutely had to choose I would vote A, because I've noticed that most girls that wear makeup generally look about as attractive, if not more attractive, when they don't wear it.
I think C is kind of nice. If the girl has complexion problems I can see why they wear more makeup, but that can give a very false impression of looks. I do like eye shadow and lipstick or gloss though when not overdone.