- Yes, I would break up with my girlfriend if this happened to her.
- No, I would not break up with my girlfriend if this happened to her.
Most Helpful Guy
I would personally not break up with you but, I can't speak for all guys including your bf. It sounds like he simply didn't trust you with this other guy, and when you were still in contact with the other guy even after you promised not to be it pushed him over the edge. He obviously didn't trust you with him or talking to him, weather he was being unjustifiably jealous or not I can't say. But if he was being overly jealous its probably for the best things ended now, people like that only get worse as the relationship goes on.
Most Helpful Girl
I think it's your BF's fault for him telling you to hang out with another guy you have feelings for and then getting mad about it later. But you should have stopped talking to guy 1. I can see why he's pissed but i also see that you should have not texted guy 1 at all.