Most Helpful Guy
Most Helpful Girl
I find it hard to believe to happen legitimately, though a lot depends on why you broke up the first time around, how old you were, etc.
I was with a guy for like.. 2 years or so in high school. It was really good, spent every day together, hung out with the same crowd, etc.. Drifted towards the end of high school, broke up. About 1 year after that we had lost contact. When I turned legal I started bumping into him at a local bar and we started hanging out again. One thing led to another and it was like we jumped right back into where we left off. Or so I thought.. towards the end I was filled with a lot of suspicion/uncertainty. He ended up cheating on me.
I think I 'feel back in love' with the idea of who he had been the first time around than who he actually was now.
Take caution of that if you're in a similar position.