Has anyone dated someone that was amazing, but the were missing that something that you couldn't quite figure out, but it always nagged at you? I dated this amazing girl for 2 years. She was kind, funny, loyal, honest, and like a best friend. She is an incredible cook and artist as well. The only flaws she had were that she wasn't sexy at all (physically or mentally), I didn't find her that attractive physically (she is considered good looking, but not exactly my type), and she was extremely inexperienced with relationships. Aside from that she was pretty much perfect. I broke up because the feeling that something was off was finally too much for me. I miss her, but I feel like she wasn't the one. It's so confusing when you have a problem with something, but you can't even figure out what it is.
Most Helpful Girl
It looks like you kind of figured out the problem: she wasn't attractive to you even though she had some very good qualities. That is okay it is just strange that you gave it a shot in the beginning if you didn't feel attracted enough. It would be nice if you could stay friends since you really like her as a person.0THIS IS NOT RELEVANT ANYMORE