Most Helpful Girl
Well, probably not wrong. Honestly, you can't expect your every day person off the street to know and understand how to help someone that is suicidal. That is a lot to put on someone. Sounds like you both might be better off.
Most Helpful Guy
Without knowing all of the specifics about you situation, it is difficult to judge. If you feel good about the breakup afterward, you probably made the right decision. Obviously you are dealing with some serious issues right now. Some people can not handle being in a relationship while they figure out how to be in a healthy state of mind.