I obviously freak out and ask him wtf is going on. This was over the phone at the time because he's in the military and lives a few hours away. He gets really defensive and claims it wasn't him, then he got mad that I would even accuse him of such a thing.
Anyways, he claims that it was his brother who was playing a joke on him... He never saw the emails before I mentioned them to him. It's all pretty sketchy because the 2 weekends where these emails were sent were 2 of only a few weekends he hasn't spent with me. sketchy.
However I did check our phone records and there weren't any calls or texts from strange numbers on these days. I've never met his family, because they also live very far away and he hasn't been home in a while, but he had his brother call me and explain what happened and apologize..
Also he does not seem gay AT ALL. Like, from the very beginning I could tell how much he loves having sex with me, all the fun stuff. I still think about it months later because it freaked me out so much. Im too embarrassed to ask any of my friends what they think of it all, and I was hoping for an outsiders opinion... so, anyone?