Girls (and guys) who would you rather do/date? Holmes or Moriarty (or Watson)?

I'm talking about the Sherlock Holmes characters if that's not obvious... Think Sherlock (the modern adaptation with Cumberbatch) for an idea of the personalities I mean, but disregard the actors physical features.

In my view they're both high functioning sociopaths, but Sherlock is basically not evil... mostly. Anyway my point is they are quite similar in many respects, so if you disregard physical characteristics I'd be interested which you'd choose. You can pick Watson if you like...

I think this encapsulates the Good guy, bad guy, nice guy division.
  • (Sherlock) Holmes
    Vote A
  • Moriarty
    Vote B
  • Both ;)
    Vote C
  • Watson
    Vote D
  • All three of course...
    Vote E
  • See answers
    Vote F
Select age and gender to cast your vote:
I'm a GirlI'm a Guy
Come on people, this is a serious question. Some opinions please. :(
This sample size is way to small... more opinions please.


Most Helpful Girl

  • Watson :)
    He seems good.

    • Do you watch Sherlock? (Or have you read any of the books?)

    • Show All
    • Yes, I guessed from your username. I don't just ask everyone if they study physics...

    • Lol yea... :D

      Anyways, where are you from?

Recommended Questions


Have an opinion?

What Girls Said 0

The only opinion from girls was selected the Most Helpful Opinion, but you can still contribute by sharing an opinion!

What Guys Said 1

  • where's the option 4 "nobody" basicallly?

    • Vote F, see answers. That's implicitly saying none of them.

      Are you familiar with characters? Just imagine they have female bodies, which would you prefer?

Recommended myTakes