Most Helpful Girl
Probably because you don't flirt and ask out enough girls.
50% should quickly reject you, 25% should actually show up to the date, 5-10% you can actually build a good relationship with. If you don't actively pursue women, there's your answer.
Nothing wrong with how you look, you're quite handsome I might add. ^^
You just need to build what guys call "game". And you can only get that by reducing the fear related to courtship to the bare minimum by practicing: flirting, joking, talking to girls in general, asking them out...
Start by approaching girls you have no real interest in dating.