Most Helpful Guy
Probably because he is being honest with you.
Guys lie to girls for two reasons. One, to get her into bed. Two. She can't handle the truth.
Maybe he thinks you can handle the truth.
Principal goes into the teachers classroom and says, Mrs. Jones, I am disappointed in your class' test result. Half of your students scored below average for the class. I won't rest until they are all above average!
Most Helpful Girl
honestly girl, if this is they type of person you care about and he says that about you then he isn't the right one because a guy who really likes you would consider you to be beautiful and a 11. but if this is just some guy who is friends with benifits then ditch him. You don't need someone calling you a 5. you don't need that negative. He's being a jerk.