Most Helpful Guy
That's his problem. You deserve someone better anyway. A guy like that who wouldn't date you because you look like a Little Miss Goody Two Shoes is a guy who isn't going to be good to you in the long run anyway.
Have him take a look at this video so he can get a look at what a Little Miss Goody Two Shoes actually becomes:
Most Helpful Girl
You're attractive there's no doubt.
But this guy may have some edge to him and want a girl that's the same.
He may like girls that take risks.
People that are inside of a self box are sometimes boring to others.
Don't worry about if he feels that you aren't his type.
Trust me, there will be other guys that are into you that won't mind you being a good girl.