Most Helpful Girl
From my experience usually a guy who is extremely attractive would make me feel self conscious to approach him because I would feel like he is out of my league. For the most part, really attractive men are usually outgoing as well. So if you're shy and attractive, I would say you should work on making a move on the right girl. Why don't you spark up a conversation with her by saying, "how you been?" and if she is interested she would continue the conversation. Of course we all get rejected but if you never try, you will never meet anyone..
Most Helpful Guy
Well as you said yourself you are handsome, extremely handsome but you are shy as well, I mean 8-9/10 is very good, physically that's an excellent rating, so the reason you may not be getting a woman is most probably because of your personality.
Otherwise I don't see any other problem as to why an attractive guy can't get a woman. Just try to be more confident and try to show it in your body language.