Most Helpful Guy
go with your gut. you can take all our opinions into account but go with your gut. personality goes a long way obviously as it doesn't fade with age. a good looking person matters to a lot of people, but if you allow yourself to experience different things, you may open up your world to an entire new perspective you would have never dreamed of that may take you through endless years of happiness. its your choice.
Most Helpful Girl
It's usually easier for women to be content with personality than men. It's not a good or bad thing---it just is. There have been plenty of guys I'm not physically attracted to but would love to be with just because they're so likable.
Just take it slow. If you genuinely develop feelings for him then his outer appearance will no longer be any sort of turn-off. But if you find yourself consistently discontent with his looks then let him go find a girl who DOES truly like him.