Most Helpful Guy
Coming from a Tinder veteran with 1000+ matches:
The point of pictures is to convey your lifestyle. By choosing 5 duplicate preppy pictures you are conveying yourself as being very pretentious which is a TURN OFF. Choose one picture - they are actually really good pictures - but choose one. Then choose another picture of you outdoors. Then another picture of you enjoying a hobby. Etc.
I would choose the first one or the fourth one if I were you. Women on online dating apps tend to respond well to pictures where you;re looking away and not smiling (believe it or not).
Hope this helps.