As a guy, what do you prefer?
Most Helpful Girl
Athletic can be too casual (shorts, t-shirts, etc) to go to some places.
Preppy is too hard to have fun in (you always have to worry about ripping/tearing or staining something).
It's hard to go wrong with a collared shirt & jeans.
Most Helpful Guy
Every occasion has it's outfit. If I play tennis or golf then yes I will dress preppy. I grew up a prep somewhat and I don't wear it much anymore. I am more of a jeans button down oxford not tucked in guy or a nice t shirt.