Most Helpful Guy
Yeah. It can draw attention to the lips, which is a good thing. "Natural look" is completely subjective - most guys don't know the difference between no makeup and a little makeup, and might think a little makeup looks more "natural" than no makeup.
If you think it looks good, then go for it. You're probably right.
Most Helpful Girl
Some do, some don't. Many don't really care.
I loooovveee matte lipstick though. Lip gloss isn't really my style.