Most Helpful Guy
Damn! that's a big eyeball, lol. Well, blue eye-shadow looks real good but not all the time, on some occasions it will look really good. I think for black eye-liner you are going a bit heavy there but maybe it is because of the image quality. Also, your eyes without make-up are really nice. Especially as it seems you have big eyes, and big eyes look really cute without anything on. Good Luck with your choices.
Most Helpful Girl
It's a lot easier to tell with a full face photo rather than just a close up photo, because then we get the real effect of the make up on your eyes in relation to your face. i know you said "guys", but thats my input. :)