Most Helpful Guy
I don't think that most guys like dramatic makeup. I do think makeup is important and is definitely a serious art. That's why there are so many makeup gurus on YouTube and it has actually coincided perfectly with the huge run up in asset prices with makeup stocks (L'Oreal, Sally Beauty, Ulta, etc.) Makeup is a huge, huge deal right now!
That said, I truly believe that when someone says that someone wears "too much makeup", what's really happening is that the woman that they're looking at simply puts on makeup poorly. Someone who puts on makeup correctly should look like they slept really well the previous night. Guys will say that they like a women with no makeup but the truth is, the women that they think are wearing very little makeup typically have plenty of makeup on -- they just know how to put it on.
Most Helpful Girl
I think something in between like natural/light make up, or something that highlights what's already there and a more dramatic look just on special occasions (clubbing, parties, weddings)