Most Helpful Girl
When I used to be "emo" or "scene" some years ago, I was immediately attracted to guys who were 'emo' and 'scene' themselves, who loved the same music as I did, liked anime/manga, were quiet but cool...
And I all in all hated jocks, preppy guys, the social butterflies, ect. (You get the idea...)
But that was just me. Every girl is different.. I'd guess that most emo girls likes emo guys.