Most Helpful Guy
It is all in how you carry yourself. Do you seem fun? Would I want to hang around you? Can you hold an intellectual conversation? If a girl is good looking, she is good looking there is little stuff she can do, but what works on you and what individuals guys find sexy is so varied, I wouldn't obsess over it. If instance a hardcore punk girl probably won't be attracted to a cardigan wearing guy who lives in the Hamptons and goes to Harvard and the guy probably won't be attracted to her, her multi colorer crazy hair, piercings an tats.