Most Helpful Guy
The main issue I find is that I get so used to seeing a girl in so much make-up, that when I see her w/out it, I am shocked purely how different she looks. It's not that she is ugly - on the contrary (I prefer minimal makeup) it's just for some people, they are barely recognizable. This is just applicable to those who use a lot of make up...girls who use it subtely it doesn't result in the same reaction.
To answer your question, it depends on the girl, but I believe in less is more. as long as you look natural it's fine in my books.