Most Helpful Girl
You don't dress modestly, you dress normally. (This would be modest. link At least in my opinion.)
I think the clothes you said you wouldn't wear are also OK. I don't see how are they too revealing unless you have an insecurity to hide. They are revealing, but not slutty, if a girl knows how to wear them and has a body that doesn't make it seem too vulgar, it's OK.
Don't care whether people like your style, if it's too modest, let it be. It's yours.
Also don't grow a superiority complex because you wouldn't wear something, and you conclude it automatically makes you better then all the girls that would.
If you don't, then your fine. =)