Most Helpful Guy
I actually do like girls that care about their look, but not obsessed with it. It may sound hypocritical, but while I don't like girls that are all about shopping 24/7 at name brand stores, I do love a girl that has a sense of fashion. But, just as equally, I love a girl that's comfortable in jeans and a t-shirt as well. Ideally, I would like a girl to be balanced when it comes to "dressing up" and "being comfortable (i.e. t shirt/jeans type girl)." Girls that put excessive hours into their image and dress up EVERYDAY would just reek of high maintenance to me, but that's just my opinion.
Also, it probably has to do with the fact that I see myself as that type as well. Some days I'll want to dress a little nicer but usually my style is pretty laid back. I wouldn't like to be with a girl that would make me feel like I have to dress to impress every single day.