Would you tell a girl you like that you find another girl attractive?

[SlightlyEccentric]

Your question kinda contradicts your explanation. The question suggests he does like you, but the explanation suggests you only thought he did.

I guess by the sound of it, if you thought he was into you then you never actually confirmed it. So safe to say he probably wasn't into you. Which is better than him being confirmed into you then saying some other girl is cute.

Probably best if you just moved on from him.

[Elijah_Dude]

I think it depends on who the guy is with personality wise, aka my girl friend would respond to that comment with, “as long as you let me get railed by zak bagans” but it just depends how close you are

[FakeNIK]

We usually don't do that maybe he's not into you or maybe he's trying to make you feel jealous by the way guys only use this tactic as a final resort. Have you noticed any other signs?

[Avicenna]

No way. That is a turn off

[Yourman89]

I would if I was comfortable with the girl

[In_Trance]

He's not into you