Search Results: hanging out with friends high school

So I'm caught between three guys and would like some advice on which one I should stick with.

Guy 1: he's sweet, skinny, tan and French but he also speaks English. He's slightly taller than me (5'7) but is a year younger than me so he's in his last year of high school while I'm going on to college. I haven't known him long but he says he really wants a commitment and I don't know if I'm ready for that plus he's sort of religious

Guy 2: we dated in grade 7 he's abit chubby but really fun to be around we started hanging out more in our last year of high school. he has a bit of baggage but who doesn't but I'm not too sure that I could see him as more than a friend.

Guy 3: He's 5'10 white and skinny. he has an amazing smile and is going to the same college as me next year. He's easy to talk to and there's definitely a physical attraction between us. I feel like once I get to know him better I could really fall for him but the down side is he has a history with this girl I used to be friends with

So those are the three guys in my life right now. im not dating any of them at the moment but the option is there and I don't want to lead them on and would like some opinions on which one I should choose they're all really cool guys but the pros and con's are all very different.

This is all a very long story, but to make it short. He liked me in high school, I liked him in college. We dated briefly in high school and I broke up with him. Then we almost dated in college... except he told me he was just trying to get back at me for not liking him in high school. It was a mess. He said he was just using me to make up for his own loneliness. We never kissed or anything... it was bizarre.

Fast forward some.. I said we couldn't be friends, he begged and begged. I finally gave in b/c I realized it was doing more hurt than good... So we restarted our friendship. I hated hanging out w/ him at first b/c I didn't trust him. I kind of still don't?

He and I are really really bad at not being close friends. We actually like telling each other our secrets and hearing each other's opinions. I didn't want to be close w/ him like this ever again, but we seem to weasel our way into each other's lives no matter what. fml.

So two weeks ago I was very stressed. Over the phone he asked me when it was that I last got laid and with whom. He suggested I use it as a stress reliever. As we are NOT that close right now, I thought this was REALLY awkward! It's like he's checking in on my sex life.

Week later I got wasted and wrote him about how I thought it was a weird/awkward question. So last night... we have an ENTIRE discussion about sex and our sexual experiences. It was fine and hilarious sharing some silly things.

I just worry about getting too close with him again. I mean, where do we draw the friendship line? We both had very strong feelings for one another at some point in our lives and neither of us want to like the other again... so where do we stop telling each other things?