Justice is not payback.
@Soteris - explain to me again the difference between something that's just vs. something that's fair?Payback? I thought this Q was about getting justice for the victim?
.. Do you really think this will give justice for the victim? Like seriously?
@Soteris - So what did you have in mind instead?
How about something that actually helps the victim instead since they are the ones who actually needs something at this point, be it counseling or whatever else this specific case requires.
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
Castrating a woman does not have the same remedial effects.
@BBKAT I know, but something similar could be done?
This want for something similar for female offenders is a bad road to go down. Trying to find some way to make it "equal" between the sexes disregards the science of why castrating sex offenders is helpful to them. Cutting off a man's balls will dramatically reduce his ability to reoffend, but sterilizing a woman won't do the same. To give a woman this treatment would be a clear punishment with no benefit, whereas snipping a man is quite beneficial to him.