Most Helpful Guy
I don't really like the idea of having one person pay for everything. But the gesture is really nice. So I would recommend that you should of course offer to atlas split it and If he insists let him pay. Then either you should Inist to pay for the next date or perhaps offer to buy him some drinks, either later that night or another time.
Most Helpful Girl
Bake him cookies or make h im chocolate covered pretzels. You send a good sign if you can cook. I wouldn't do anything too over the top being a second date, but to ignore it would bw rude, i agree. And all men like food. If he says "oh! Sorry i didn't get you anything!" You have an easy out. Explain you were making sweets for all you friends and didn't want to leave him out.