Most Helpful Guy
Depends if he's into it or not.
Personally, I don't expect anything or really want anything. However, it is nice when I do get something (this year I got tshirts). Those were really nice.
My partner gave me those as well as a series of photos of us with music playing and what was essentially compliments between each photo. But not the kind where it's "you're super handsome" or something like that. It was more along the lines of stuff that she felt mattered to her.