Search Results: typical guy advice

(Heads-up, this is a little lengthy)
There's a guy from my church that I'm close friends with. We often end up just talking for ages and it's just the two of us. I think he might like me because...

He compliments me A LOT. He often says nice things like, "You're pretty good at singing!", "Wow, you're drawing's awesome!", "Nice job playing bass today.", 'Wow, you're so musically talented!" or "Oh my gosh, this tastes amazing!" whenever I bring sweets. He rarely compliments anyone else.
He pays a lot of attention to me. Whenever we're talking he doesn't really try to include anyone else in the conversation and pays attention almost to only me. The only times he doesn't it's because someone else said hi to him. Sometimes when we're walking and talking he holds the door open for me if someone else walks through, he says, "Wow, so rude." He also comments on if anyone is even remotely rude to me. Sometimes he and I are in two different groups of conversation and he's in the other side of the room I notice him look at me a lot.
He gets close to me. Oftentimes if I'm sitting alone he'll sit next to me. One time when this happened he made me laugh, and he brought his face really close to mine.
He tries to make me laugh a lot and talks to me a lot in general. He likes making me laugh about 80% of the time during our conversations by cracking really stupid puns. He also sings with me a lot. But recently he asked me to sing a love song with him. He asked me to sing "Love is an Open Door," from "Frozen," and after that he asked me to sing "I see the Light" from "Tangled" with him.
I think he might like me, but I'm so confused! I don't like him, so I'm trying to not lead him on if he does have feelings for me. I just need advice on how to not string a guy on, and I actually like his best friend so I'm not in denial. Please help! (Please note that he isn't a flirty guy, he's your typical nice guy)