Search Results: if you had a clone

i have two vary different types of star wars games. one is a duel based game (star wars jedi academy (mod) knights of the force) in this, there is large selection of characters that you can play as and characters you can either fight with or against (only single person for it is a single player mod). so for example, i could reenact the final battle in episode, 1, 2, or 3. as well as make a custom match of my own 1 on 1, 2 on 2, 3 on 3. etc. there are soldiers like clones, droids, and stormtroopers so i could do a battle in it, but if i desired just a battle (army against army), i would go with the second opinion (basically the blaster battles are not as cool but it can be done, but the up side to the battles in kotf is that i could do clones against clone, clones against stormtroopers, clones against rebels, cis against stormtroopers, and other factions against them. so there's that).

the other one is a battle based star wars game. and when i say battle, i mean army against army. choose one, and with your army, fight the other. of course i'm speaking of battlefront 2 (the best one, aka the classic). there are a huge selection of mods for this game (for pc) but most are battle based for this is a battle based game. but with that said there are few duel mods that allow 1 on 1 (at least). haven't seen 2 on 1 or 2 on 2 or anything like that. so basically the same as what i mention with the duel. the other opinion can be done in this star wars game style, but it's not as good/defined as the other, but fun can still be had with it (and of course unlike kotf, the duel mods for battlefront 2 are not all in one as kotf is, so you'd have to hunt all of those mods that you'd desire down to make a complete mod list for battlefront 2, or else it's just a regular battlefront 2)
now that i put the two choices out there and explained what i mean by them,
which would you prefer and why?