Search Results: should a girl ask for the guys number

I have a lot of history with this one guy, but we haven't very much I common other than that. All my friends are pressuring me to date him because he really likes me. This leads me to be kinda flirty. The only issue, I have a way larger crush on his brother.

I don't hang out with his bro very much except for parties where he usually watches out for me. He's really kind and sometimes I am too nervous to talk to him but other times it's so easy because we just understand each other. He is super athletic and attractive and every girl in my school likes him but he doesn't seem to be into anyone.

I'm starting to think he's irritated by me because even when he's online he almost never reads my Facebook messages. Despite this HE GAVE ME his phone number to text him in town when he sometimes does have service. Heck randomly today he asked if we could hang out one-on-one so idek.

I also have this friend who is high maintenance who also likes him. She called dibs but later explained it doesn't mean anything. She was there and demanded he give her his phone number too. He always gave her more attention but that probably makes sense given her personality.

So am I in the wrong? Should I date the younger brother because of history and he's obviously infatuated with me? Should I chase the older brother because I like him A LOT? Maybe I should stay away from both of them so that I don't hurt their friendship?