Search Results: getting back with someone who cheated

So basically I want to see what guys/girls look for in their dating prospects, spouses, etc... I've seen all sorts of "oh, I want a nice guy who's sweet and funny" or "I want a girl who's cute and well-mannered" only to be surprised by the choices they make at the end. Vote for one of the choices below please. :)

Given, the choices are really generalized, but you can add your own touch as to what you prefer within an answer below.

Let's say there are 5 girls or guys at a table and they all have expressed a clear interest in you. You don't know any of them, but you do have first impressions. Which one would you "go out" with?

A: Mr./Miss Hot & Sexy. This person literally looks like a model. Just looking at him/her, takes your breath away. He/she is very nice to you and clearly knows how to talk to a person of the opposite gender (maybe a player/playeress?). He/she is clearly giving off signals that they like you. You just have to come and get it.

B: Mr./Miss Wealthy. Getting into a relationship with this person would mean covering your expenses for however long you are together. Marrying him/her would guarantee a life of comfort. Also, he/she is pretty good-looking. Definitely someone you would be proud to call your partner. Very well-mannered when he/she talks to you, but he/she does attract a lot of attention from the other sex. You'll need to keep a close eye to make sure some other girl/guy doesn't snatch your partner away.

C: Mr./Miss Talented. He/she is pretty much good at everything they touch. He/she can sing, dance, play instruments, speak in public, play sports, etc... People envy his/her abilities and you being with him/her would make you the envy of your peers. Oh, he/she can also be a little cocky, but usually in a joking manner (or is he/she not joking?). He/she is probably the most interesting person you've ever met. You're inevitably attracted to him/her but so is everyone else...

D: Mr./Miss Popular. He/she knows people like the back of their palm. He/she knows what to say, knows what to do. Everybody loves him/her and to top it all off, he/she is not cocky. In fact, he/she is very humble and modest. Popular AND Humble? hmmm.. Did I mention he/she is still very popular with his/her many exes?

E: Mr. Nice Guy/Girl. He/she is not as hot, wealthy, talented, or popular as the other options, BUT there is one thing they can guarantee. For one thing, you'll know that he/she will never cheat on you and will respect you on an equal level. He/she is the sweetest girl/guy, but yet, they aren't nice, nice. They aren't wimpy pushovers, and you find him/her kinda attractive. However, being with him/her won't exactly get a lot of oo's and ahh's from your peers. In fact, they might make fun of you.

Be honest with your answers ;). I know most of us are more shallow than we care to admit. I for one would probably pick C just because I like talented girls, even if they aren't really really good-looking. Miss Popular/Nice Girl are tied for 2nd.