Search Results: choosing between two girls

It all started this fall with a church friend who's name was let's say Nate who I asked to Homecoming as I liked him and we were becoming friends. He liked me at the time but I didn't know until later. Nate and I were so close to dating but then I started rehearsing for a musical I was in and was literally swept off my feet by another guy. (Jack) so them came the decision between Nate and Jack. Let's just say I chose very wrong and friendzoned Nate before even really getting to know Jack. Nate blew up a little and I felt really bad. Jack ended up treating me like crap and I wanted to go back to Nate but he already had another girl he was interested in. So I told my best friend of 3 years that I might be interested in more than a friendship and he said I have loved you this whole time. We almost dated on the spot however we were hesitant because we didn't want yo ruin our amazing friendship and he can be a little dirty and he jokes around with me a lot. Not in a bad way. So I overheard at church that some other guy was trying to get between Nate and this new girls relationship. i hadn't talked to him since he blew up on me for friend zoning him. I pulled him aside at church and poured my heart out to him and said if there was any chance his other relationship didn't work out that I would be there if he wanted to take me back and he said to give him time but he hears what I was saying. Now after seeing Nate and this other girl blossom in their relationship even as someone tries to get in between them I realize how much I miss him and want him back now more than ever. But them I still have my best friend who admits to actually loving me this whole time and i don't know which guy to pursue more. Nate is extremely attractive but not available at the moment, and mark is sweet and he loves me but I am not as attracted to him and we don't want to ruin our friendship. I need some advice/guidance.
Thanks in advance for reading this!

So, I am torn between 4 groups of friends. The first group consist of my best friends since 5th grade (we are in 8th grade now) They are always really mean to me. The only reason I am still friends with them is because my two very best friends are in that group. The second group are 3 girls who are all really into band. They are always nice to me, but I'm afraid since they are all in band and I'm not, I wouldn't get included in stuff because they hang out in band 24/7. Before I explain the next group I want to say that I go to a Jr. Senior highschool which means that I would be able to see the next group of friends after they get into 9th grade. It would just be my freshman year I wouldn't have friends because we all are in one building so we will definitely go to the same highschool. The third group is probably my favorite. They are a group of 7th graders and they are so soo SOOO nice to me. However, when I go into highschool, they will still be in jr. High, and I will be left with nobody. The fourth group is a group of 4girls and 4 guys. They are also very nice to me, and I fit in with them. (They are all in my grade.) the only downfall to them is everyone sees them as weird. I don't want to be seen like that. Which should I choose?

We will call them as 'Y' and 'P'.

Y is a flirt but he is really nice at heart and he treat me as his one and only best friend and care for me a lot but i love him madly and he knows it but as he want to join Buddhism[he will won't marry anyone] in future he said "i can't be with you i like you but i am not the right one."

P is a nice guy and he as a crush on me from past 3 years he never flirts with any girl and he just talk to me whole day[i attend his call if i am free] and he knows that i am not into him but he still wants to be my friend and he is nice even actually perfect.

P treats me like i am the one and i too treats Y as same but Y ignores it and i ignore P efforts.

Girl A: Very pretty face but average body
Girl B: Average face but killer body

Say they both have similar personalities