Search Results: wrong to be protective

please dont take this question the wrong way, i dont know how to phrase it. These guys all like me and i kinda like all of them. I dont know what to do and i dont want to hurt anyone. :(
Guy 1- been my best guy friend for ages, he's so sweet, kind, funny, and we're really close. He's matured a lot in the last few months and i have to admit i really like him. He's always liked me and we've always had a conncetion bu tignored it because we were "just friends". He's made a few grand romantic gestures but it can't so anywhere because one of my close friends likes him.
Guy 2- Is probably the most attractive guy in my school, and i am attracted to him but i dont "like" him and dont know how to let him down gently. He's so lovely, fit, smart, nice and funny, and he drew me this beautiful rose and told his friend he likes me. I feel really special and lucky buy dont feel the same.
Guy 3- Met at a festival a year ago and is literally perfect- we get on so well. We went on a few dates and i really really liked him but we drifted apart. After a few months we're talking again. He's so perfect he ticks every box. He's smart, witty, funny, sweet, charming, honest, supportive, loyal, everything. He plays drums and sports, is about to get his lisence, really healthy. Its hard to develop a further connection over text so i think we need to go on another date. Sometimes i dont feel like talking to him very much.
Guy 4- the most confusing, frustrating guy ever. I have liked him for about a year anf a half. No one understands our connection but its undeniable. Last year i liked him sooo much but nothing happened because we never talekd about our feelings (he's so confusing), but he liked me a lot. This year we're close friends and i can't escape my feelings for him, i can't get over him. He likes me too i think, he does the sweetest things and he's really protective and gets jealous. I can just tell, but i dont want to play cat and mouse with him.
I hate this word but who should i "Pick"?