Search Results: dress to impress

A friend of friends has moved back to the US from Australia. Now people have told me he's hilarious, he's sweetie, they like him better than his siblings, etc. By rights, he sounds like a good guy. I like the siblings so no issue there.

But the four times I've sort of met him in passing I haven't been impressed. He hasn't done anything offensive, it's not like he looks/dresses like a bum, etc. Yes I should get to know him at least before making decisions but they say trust 'gut instinct'.

A friend of mutual friends has just come back to the US from years in Australia. Now a number of people have referred to him as hilarious, he's better than his siblings, etc. I've heard one say he's a troublemaker.

Now I'm someone who gives people the benefit of the doubt until they do something that crosses lines anyway so the 'troublemaker' dub isn't a factor. I go off 'instinct' more as I have got a very good judge of character.

And the two times I've encountered him I haven't been impressed.
Thing is, we haven't said a word to each other. I am just going off observations. He hasn't actually done anything offensive (hasn't been rude), he isn't threatening, and he dresses decent enough. There's nothing that easily comes to mind... I just him a bit off-putting.

So am I being too judgmental or not?