Search Results: found unattractive

-Backstory-
Throughout my life, there have been many girls that hit on me. I just finished my first semester of college and girls still hit on me. I don't talk to girls much AT ALL, but whenever a girl has the opportunity, they approach and say stuff like "you're very attractive" and one girl was even curious and asked "do you get hit on a lot?". This of course makes me very flattered and i'm gracious for the compliments but I can't help but notice that almost out of all the girls that hit on me ever, I only found one pretty cute and the other alright (I don't mean to be rude). Again, I don't talk to girls much at all so I don't get much exposure to hot girls anyways, but my question is should I be overestimating my looks based off these girls that hit on me and the things they say even though I don't find them attractive at all?

I read this comment on this forum (2 years old):
''let's face it when a girl is with a less attractive guy no one looks twice unless he looks like shrek next to her. when a girl is with a really handsome guy and she's not as good looking we all know people may look at them funny.''

How true do you think this is? I was on the train and #nohomo... he wasn't a model but a 8-9/10 looking guy who was also tall and looked like a 'nice' guy (aka not street/thugish) was with a pretty average looking girl. I personally didn't think much of it... but I did notice a few women look at them both... and not in a standard glance it was sort of a glare of confusion (Assuming they found him attractive and were a bit jealous or just found it bullshit).
Do any of you ladies or guys have any experiences where you were with a somewhat significantly better looking so and people were giving you off looks?