Search Results: guys notice hair

I went on Tinder, matched with a guy I had a huge crush on in high school. He gave me his number and we text. He's 28 now and I'm 24. We were in band but he never noticed me or so I thought...
Last night I went over to his house for the first time to hang out. We talked a lot, like if we knew each other really well! I met his roommate and his best friend!

Here is what I thought was weird:
1. He remembered me from High School (I didn't think he noticed me in band). He remembered what instrument I played and what section I was in.
2. We cuddled but he spooned me on his couch (when we had privacy.) Like he didn't want to let go.
3. His palms were sweaty, he was having anxiety (he told me) and was super nervous just by sitting next to me.
4. I pointed out a guy that was attractive in a show we were watching. He was criticizing on how the guy looked as if he was jealous! He kept saying "His nose is too big! Mine is smaller! I have more facial hair than he does! I'm more tan than he is!!"
5. We had sex but he swore he didn't plan it. Which he kept talking throughout the whole time. 🙄 He was nervous during sex, even though he claims to have been with 8 girls before me.

What is this Guy's deal? I can't pin point it.