Girls, Bad boy or a good guy?

[MiAmora]

Girls, what would you choose:
1) a bad boy, night rides, workaholic, talks a lot about himself, always talking about cars, but he is very caring, always gets you
2) a good guy, very careful, lives from day to day, similar opinions, but he wants more care from you than he can provide to you and is lazy

[Anonymous]

what is actually good about 'your good guy'? caring would normally be a good guy trait in my world