Which girl would you date?

[Kaylafearton]

24 or 23 year old girl? Assuming both are equal in level of attractiveness and had a similar career? Would most men choose the younger one because that is most ideal and it’s the younger the better.

[V_Injector]

The ages are so close that I don't think I would consider that factor.

But I understand the general question and will tell you that yes, it's a lot like picking up a gallon of milk. How much time is left on the expiration date? Obviously, the freshest is probably going to last the longest.

Lifestyle can make that shelf life a bit longer or a lot shorter. For instance, if one is already chubby and showing signs of overeating, then obviously I won't have as much time with that one because she'll get fat faster.

One might be inclined to argue the older one is more mature and will be more reasonable to deal with. I would counter that argument with probable body count, and baggage that might make her a fucking headache to deal with as compared to the other one. I'm probably going to have more fun with the younger one, while the older one has already had her fun and she just wants to be serious, play no games, and shit test me about a bunch of shit I never did to her (it was other men).

I'm just putting hypotheticals out there. The two individual women are so close in age that I think their behaviors are going to be the ultimate deciding factor.

Or I would try to figure out how to sleep with both of them. They want to have a threesome with me and they just don't know it yet. I have to teach them that's what they want.

[AviatorTom]

24 and 23 are, for all intents and purposes, the same age. Guys would not treat them differently.

[Kaylafearton]

Not the same age, one is younger

[Kaylafearton]

And would be more youthful

[AviatorTom]

Thanks for MHO

[HawkPerception]

I mean... I don't generally judge based on age. I'd date a 50 year old and I'd also date a 20 year old. But in this specific and extremely unlikely scenario where you have 2 girls that are equal in pretty much every category other than age, yes... I would choose the younger girl even though the year is pretty much no difference.

[Kaylafearton]

Most guys would ):

[HawkPerception]

I don't think it's anything to be upset about. The younger you are, the more of your life you have ahead of you.

I wouldn't be upset if a 35 year old girl chose to be with a guy that's younger than me if he was the same in every other category. It's fair game. Everyone is free to have their preferences. Men generally prefer girls younger than themselves and women generally prefer guys older than themselves. That's just the way the dynamic is.

[ohsheeT]

Age you wouldn't have anything to do with it it's who has the more beautiful heart who is kinder who is smart who is happy who can smile it has nothing to do with their job or anything like that it's who they are within

[Finchie40]

Their age wouldn’t be a determination , it would be her heart and how she treats me that would determine who I would choose

[Summeroflove]

I wouldn’t lol. If one was a mean person and the other one wasn’t

[Avicenna]

There is barely any difference in age between them. It makes no difference in this case.

[thearchjoker]

younger is better though a 1 year difference isn't a big deal if it were a 3 or 4 year gap than it begins to matter

[Kaylafearton]

Even if it isn’t a big deal, 1 year still would count right?

[thearchjoker]

yes but its not something you would usually take to much of a note about unless your like a teen and than it matters

[Lionman95]

I don´t put that much weight on age that I would prefer a 23 year old woman over a 24 year old just because she´s a year younger. Age is important to me but more as a marker whether we are both part of the same generation as I get a long better with women that are broadly in my generation rather than being way younger or older than me.

[RebelinSteel]

I would hazard a guess that no one (other than friends and family) who could say which girl was 23 and which was 24. Now if both were to say their ages and a guy chose based on age, then that is bloody weird. It’s the person not that one is 23 and the other is 24. Anyone going age related is weird when it’s 23 n 24.

[Berethor]

The younger the better, though 1 year is not much and none of them is a Christmas cake.

https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Christmas%20Cake

[HighValue]

They are only one year apart so it makes no difference. Whichever one has better morals, a better past, has similar interests as I do, is loyal, affectionate, cooperative, and realizes that certain careers can make her LESS attractive/appealing, but no career adds to her attractiveness. I know, many women that focus on a career and spend years getting a degree (and often loads of debt) get upset when they find out that it adds nothing to their appeal as a partner.

[morganherrel]

An intelligent and educated woman is far more attractive to me, especially when she is professionally accomplished! Sometimes that requires financial investment to achieve.

[Twalli]

Probably the one I see next. That's how I picked my fiancée. I narrowed it down to her and another girl. The other girl is about a year younger than me, while my fiancée is 5 years older than me. When I decided to ask one of thrm out, I saw my fiancée next first, so it was her.

[morganherrel]

Based. Read the poem "The Road Not Taken" by Robert Frost (:

[Twalli]

@morganherrel honestly there's always a "what if?", but after 6 years, you pretty much stop caring.

[morganherrel]

haha yes the "what if"
but that's not what the poem is about

[Twalli]

@morganherrel I know what it's about. It was my senior quote in 2009.

[morganherrel]

@Twalli I never said otherwise by the way, though I'm not sure how a senior quote indicates understanding. Sorry my reference didn't resonate. Cheers

[Maybe_Maybe_not]

Extremely weird example for this question, there is no difference between a 23yo and a 24yo ! What makes you think there is? 😆

[strateguy632]

But there is because 23 is a year younger.

[Maybe_Maybe_not]

@strateguy632 What's the point of being literal about time units that have no psychological significance lol

[Kaylafearton]

The 23 year old is younger

[Maybe_Maybe_not]

Is this hidden camera prank? 🤣

[Maybe_Maybe_not]

@Kaylafearton damn it where do you see actual significance in a 365 years gap, it has no meaning in human interactions, do you understand that maths do not apply in this context? Or am I going to explain obviously obvious obviousity for hours? LOL

[Maybe_Maybe_not]

365 years, well, I meant days 😆

[RavVid]

No two girls are going to be equal and career is not a factor. More it is nature that is more important.

Also one might like me more than the other and if I fancied both about equally, I'd end up with her.

[MisterWack]

I choose my girlfriend over both of them….
Beyond age, attractiveness, and career path in life I choose character, priorities, and personality above all else.

[Anonymous]

In this situation the age isn’t a big factor. They’re both pretty young, only a year apart maybe only even months apart. Now if it was a girl who was in her mid to late 30s vs the 23 year old, probably the younger girl.

[Anonymous]

The only reason I'd chose the younger one is because it'd probably give her one more baby-making year.

[ProbablyClueless]

Those ages are so close that it wouldn't affect my decision. I tend to prefer women closer to my age though, so I would generally lean towards the 24 year old.

[sawno]

24 year old since 23 feels to large of an age difference.

[Kaylafearton]

Really?

[sawno]

The 23 year old would have to be super mature for me not to feel like I am taking advantage.

[BadApple69]

1 year makes no difference to me. But to answer your question, I would date both. 😉

[morganherrel]

It makes practically no difference compared to the myriad other things that are more important.

[Juxtapose]

A single year is not going to make or break the decision. I would decide based on other factors.

[Vegasrunner]

There's no significant difference in age to answer that question. For all we know their days could be less than 24hours apart.

[Med_guy1978]

The age isn't a problem even if one was 20 and the other 30, the rest would be down to chemistry 🧪

[KostasKouvalis]

The 24 year old because she's closer to my age

[Anonymous]

One year younger is not much of a difference.

If they are equally attractive, most guys would date the one who has more likable personality.

[LiamJHayden]

The one who seems more likely to be faithful.

[Anonymous]

Neither. Because I tried dating a women 15 years. younger than me once... notice I said ONCE! I wouldn't ever want to do that again.

[Anonymous]

Both are young but you could argue the 24yo has had a little more time to get things in place.

[BetaBucks]

23 yo for that massive 1.25% gain in longevity

[Kaylafearton]

Are you serious?

[strateguy632]

the younger the better.

[strateguy632]

Tragic that i must add, "this is in the context of age 23".