Guys which girl would you find more appealing and why?

since both have good personalities...then I cant' just choose based on facts...I mean when a person mature one discovers that the most important things is how we "click" if you know what I mean...like for example both girl and boy are great yet they might not click with each other...so...as I said, I choose who I feel comfortable with regardless anything else.
Depends on how tall the Girl 1 is
Cause right now Girl 2 is winning just cause of height
I'm 5'8''
Girl 1 is 5'7" and girl 2 is about 5'3.
Opinion
3Opinion
Both sound reasonably attractive. It would be based on how we connect and which one seemed more attracted to me.
Girl 2. Naturally outgoing women are more attractive to me.
Girl 1, since I am tall, and other reasons
Most Helpful Opinions