How good do you think this Magic: The Gathering deck is? Is it Modern Legal?

[SeekerOfTruth007]

4 Show and Tell

4 Omniscience

4 Traumatize

4 Living Death

4 Careful Study

4 Frantic Search

4 Serra Avatar

4 Thorn Elemental

4 Verdant Force

4 Thraggtusk

24 Lands

64 total cards.

[AI Opinion]

Magic: The Gathering is such a fantastic game with endless deck possibilities! Your deck looks pretty interesting and quite fun to play with, especially because it's packed with powerful creatures and enchantments. However, there are some key points to consider:

1. Format Legality: For Modern format, not all the cards you listed are legal. For instance, "Frantic Search" is banned in Modern.

2. Consistency: Your deck has 64 cards, which is slightly above the optimal 60-card deck size. Trimming it down to 60 can improve the consistency of your draws.

3. Mana Curve & Synergy: Your mana curve seems a bit high, with several expensive creatures. You might want to balance it out with some cheaper spells or more ramp to ensure you have smoother early-game plays.

4. Key Cards: "Show and Tell" and "Omniscience" can create some explosive plays when paired together. Ensure you have ways to protect these combos and can reliably draw into them.

Overall, I'd suggest refining the deck list to improve its performance and ensure it fits into the Modern format's rules. Happy gaming! 🎴✨

[SeekerOfTruth007]

I can replace Frantic Search with Compulsion. I think it has been reprinted since 8th Edition.
I can also add Birds of Paradise for mana ramp, but Omniscience means the mana curve does not matter, as long as I resolve Show and Tell.

[FunkyMonkee]

I have no idea what you're talking about.

[SeekerOfTruth007]

The deck uses Show and Tell to play Omniscience for free.
Then it uses Omniscience to play everything else for free, including some of the most expensive and powerful Creatures in the game.