Is Marshals the worst show on TV, or just a disappointing Yellowstone spinoff?

[msc545]

Generic Procedural Feel: Many feel the show trades the prestige, sweeping Montana vistas, and heavy family politics of Yellowstone for a formulaic, standard-issue "Dad cop" network format. Critics at The Daily Beast have slammed it as an embarrassing network procedural that lacks the edge of its predecessor.

Disjointed Writing & Plot: Discussions on Reddit reflect widespread fan consensus that the writing feels rushed, the dialogue unnatural, and the character arcs underdeveloped.

Unpopular Creative Choices: The series kicks off with the off-screen death of Monica Dutton and pivots Kayce into a standard U. S. Marshals unit, which left many original Yellowstone loyalists feeling like the character's hard-earned happy ending.

[NathanDavis]

I've only watched 1883... and I liked it

Yellowstone itself, I have not watched it... but based on that description about "Marshalls" it doesn't sound anything like the usual plots for these series, lol

[msc545]

1883 was very good, and Yellowstone was also very good, in my opinion. Marshals, on the other hand, is amateur. The so-called actors stand around in circles and read lines to each other.

[Iron_Man]

I haven’t seen that. I heard Yellowstone is good

[msc545]

Yellowstone is actually really good. I enjoyed it. Marshals is a nightmare. These people stand around in circles and read their lines to each other. That's how bad the acting is.

[Iron_Man]

Well, I’m not gonna watch Marshalls

[msc545]

Yeah, don't waste your time with that one. Best one of all, if you've not seen it, is Landman. I think you would really enjoy that.