What's nerdier... dungeons and dragons or magic the gathering?

[CommieDearest]

Before people trip shit I don't have a problem with either, I just want to know which one is classified as nerdier.

D&D

Magic

They're both awesome!

I've never heard of those

[RedThread]

I vote C and I play magic every Friday and think it's the SHIIIIIIIIIIT.
I'm a regular spellslinger baby.

fc08.deviantart.net/.../...quiorra9000-d559uvg.jpg

41.media.tumblr.com/.../...ciMUOH1ruj7jlo1_500.jpg

www.quickmeme.com/.../...c7d359272c55d8ffedfe5.jpg

[CommieDearest]

That last one... smh.

[RedThread]

yeah it's pretty bad.. I just read the words really quickly and copied and pasted it.

[CommieDearest]

Rude

[RedThread]

ur momma

[CommieDearest]

I told her you said that and she said "tell him to stfu" hahhahahahahaha

[RedThread]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yhim4KRa8I

take that.

[CommieDearest]

I'm blocking you haha

[Hephaestus]

Both are awesome!

I'd say dungeons though, for the sheer principle some folk get really... really into it and get rather agitated if you fuck up

media2.giphy.com/media/CrAeSxnvPeXVC/200w.gif

[CommieDearest]

Holy shit that gif lol

[Hephaestus]

Hey...
fucker shouldn't have tried to back out of the cave where the orc king sat.

[Bluemax]

As a former player myself, I'd say D&D.

In high school, I knew one guy who claimed to have been descended of elves. No shit. I was at a Denny's a few months back with a woman I was dating. We spotted a group playing some RPG over in the corner. I told her I used to be one of those guys. She laughed and said I should go over there and tell them, "This could be you" and she would make out with me.

[Kinstrome]

I have a brother who plays Magic (and has flown places to play tournaments) and who also played D&D for a stretch, so I have a little secondhand knowledge. They seem to both be pretty full-time commitments that require getting into the culture if you want to enjoy them. Of the two, I'd say Magic is a tiny bit more mainstream, since it's comparable to popular playing cards-based games like Poker.

[Anonymous]

They're both awesome! i1127.photobucket.com/.../...f.com-gif-maker_3.gif

[Klaatu51]

D&D but in their earlier days i guess... back in 70s-80s, when RPGs weren't so known to the public :)

[Anonymous]

uuugghh.

They're both... nerdy.

Flashbacks to roommates... cheez-its smashed on the floor... untrimmed toenails and long hair... movie references... trying to do homework...

[thesweetness]

definitely dungeons and daggers. i used to play world of warcraft for a while and even then i used to make fun of people playing d&d

[Slugworth99]

I grew up playing Dungeons & Dragons (I still have my first edition blue rule book). It is truly the landmark nerd game!

[Anonymous]

I've heard of dungeons and dragons because of the nerd thing, I haven't heard of the other one though. So I'm gonna say dungeons and dragons.

[atomique]

The are equals? I have only played Magic a few times

[Illusive_Man]

They are both fucking AWESOME!
D&D especially!

[ryanrhino]

Neither is nerdy. LARPing on the other hand...

[CommieDearest]

Yeah I couldn't put that in the poll, not fair lol

[No_Drama_]

Hey... I loved D&D when I was a kid! Lol

[emerald77]

They both are.