Search Results: healthy fat girls

Hello all! I'm working on a little side project of mine. I'm curious to see what men prefer in regards to women. Girls are free to answer as well, of course, but this will focus primarily on the guys.

Men, read the following two scenarios, and decide which girl you would prefer as a quick fling/short-term dating relationship, and which girl you'd prefer as a long-term/marriage relationship.

Girl A: She's thin, but not incredibly skinny. Modest breasts, attractive exterior, few outer flaws. However, she is very self-conscious about her appearance. She will rarely accept compliments you give her, and even she almost never believes you if you say positive things about the way she looks. She is always genuinely down about her looks, not for attention but simply because she does not believe herself to be beautiful. This impacts her daily routine (i. e. she won't wear certain clothes because she immediately hates how they look, won't go out if she doesn't look good/thinks she looks fat, etc.)
Imagin something like this:


Girl B: She's thicker. She's healthy, but not perfect body-i. e. a bit of a tummy, not carved without perfections, stretch marks or cellulite in some places. This girl is confident in herself, and does not care what other people think. She accepts herself and her body, and lives her life as she chooses. She is healthy but has weaknesses to sweets every so often like most. She won't let what people say about her get her down. Imagine something like this:


Now, personality wise both are kind, affectionate and understanding towards their partner and towards others. Only difference is how they see themselves, and how this affects their lives. Both women are good people.

Now, which woman would you rather have a certain relationship with, and why?

This is something I may try for a sociology project, so consider this a test run ;)
Thanks in advance!

Edit: This is just a survey, no attack on any shapes, please be respectful in comments.

So I'm 17, and used to weigh 145lbs (I'm also 5'4) and over the last 2 years I've totally changed my diet, and Started eating a LOT healthier. I eat around 1700-1800 calories a day and I'm not very active except for walking/biking so I'm not under eating. But the thing is, ever since I reached and started to maintain my final goal of 120lbs, I haven't had my period. I'm not sure why though because I'm not under weight. My last normal period was when I weighed 130. So, should I like try to gain some weight back to see if it returns? Its hard because I seriously only gain weight in my stomach, so when I had my period I was a slim girl with a chubby stomach, which I'm not too crazy about. (I've tried strength training to gain muscle, and I still only gain stomach fat. Genetics?)