Guys, or girls who date girls, which girl would you choose?

Question

Also, they could be any race Pinterest is just overrun with white women! :(

MCheetah · Accepted Answer

The tall blonde looks hot, but her personality is trash. She seems like the type of "modern woman" who'd be on OnlyFans. Plus the pic used for her looks like a transwoman (that mannish Boxer's Jaw and chin is hard to miss). Next!

The short ugly brunette is a contradiction. You can't be "a bit shy, a bit confident" at the same time. Those two are complete opposites. Unless she was faking her arrogance and was really bashful and timid on the inside, but hides it well. But that wouldn't be just "a bit." Either way, she's got nothing going for her. No looks, slightly arrogant personality, and too slender for my tastes. Only the one relationship thing is even remotely a positive. She's probably the one I'd want the least, as option A at least has looks going for her.

I actually knew a girl just like option D in the past. A California, raven-haired, blue eyed *gorgeous* bartender named Marla. She was kinda my friend (she wanted to hook up with me, but I couldn't trust her, so you could argue I "Friendzoned" her from friends with benefits.) She wasn't exactly tall (5'7" instead of 5'9"-5'11"), but she was slim, a 34D, made good money on the side modeling plus bartending, and never married or divorced. The problem? She was batsh*t insane. Literally crazy. I'm sure there's an exact medical diagnosis for it; Bipolar, Histrionic Personality Disorder, or whatever. The point is, women like this are always trouble and have more baggage than LAX.

Option C checks all the boxes I want except she's under 5'6". If she was 5'9"-6'0", she'd be ideal for me. I'm willing to look past a few hookups in the past as long as she doesn't do that anymore. Yeah, besides being like 5'0"-5'4", she's perfect for me.

Shiningtempest · Accepted Answer

If I had to choose, I'd go with Option B since she's most likely will provide me tranquility I desperately need.

victoriaxoxo · Accepted Answer

A sounds very superficial and potentially annoying. A date would her feels like it would end in drama or having to blow a lot of $ just to please her.
C would depend how chubby she is because the woman in the picture has a big belly. I would worry about spending all my days indoors because this woman isn't fit enough to do all the things I want to do.
D would be my 2nd choice although she is twice my age and that might make a weird dynamic. She might also be very busy and therefore neurotic. She might not know how to relax.
B sounds fun. She doesn't need to look as young as the woman in the picture but what I think most people find attractive about her is that she is natural. She seems like she doesn't wear much make up and is healthy and energetic. She seems like fun.

Smoke-n-Growls · Accepted Answer

I'm honestly a bit torn.

The 33yo sounds like we'd have fun, but I'm active and worry she may not like my lifestyle. I've already dated lazy and unmotivated people and we don't jive.

The 27yo sounds like my type, honestly, but I worry about her only having one relationship. That said, I've only had two "real" long term ones, so it's not like a huge gulf of experience.

But the 45yo? If she's also active and she's ok with me being younger, I'm in. I'm attracted more strongly to older people. I would worry I'm mismatched in terms of life stage, though. I wouldn't want to be a bore or slow down this lady's roll.

Wraith_Cemetery · Answer

None of them look that appealing. But, if forced to choose from the selection, then I'd go with B.

My type would be the shy vintage girl who would rather go into the world of her books than go on hookups. She loves libraries and studying in independent cafes. She dresses modestly and is kind of traditional. She only believes in monogamous relationships and is waiting for that one guy to sweep her off her feet.

Guys, or girls who date girls, which girl would you choose?

JSmuve · Answer

A is the type of girl that's here for a good time, not a long time. Get in, get off, get out with her. I'd casually date her.

B sounds like the type of girl you settle for after you've had her fill of A. Sounds like long-term relationship material.

C is the type of girl you casually hook up with when things are slow but deny to your friends about.

D just sounds too old for anything meaningful long-term. Her divorce begs questions about her relationship suitability and her propensity to travel raises questions about how expensive she is and her money habits. She'd do well as someone you casually date and go on adventures with, like a friends with benefits but if she can prove that she's a good relationship candidate, then she can move up the list pretty quickly but would lose out to a similar, but younger, woman.

(Dating) B > D > A > C (Hook-up)

Th3ft · Answer

This is too specific. Lol! There are reasons why I might date any of these girls but there are also reasons with each of them why I might not… And honestly B and C are the only two I would date for natural reasons. A and D are either so far off my spectrum that it would ONLY be about sex or money if I did date them…

Lionman95 · Answer

B mostly because of her age and we might have a similar character ( both haven't been in a long-term relationship) otherwise also D could be an option. I like about D that she's said to like to explore. But D has the problem that I'm not into significant older women hence she's 18 years older than me.

Reaper1985 · Answer

went with C because natural redheads are rare and makeup less then 5% of the world population. however B's could also work well if we had common interests since I prefer a girl with a low sexual history.

libsaretards · Answer

I voted option "B". She is in the age range I would want to date and she takes care of herself. The fact she likes to be active is a huge plus for me. She is also the right combo of shy and confident.

slatyb · Answer

At my age? Probably D but B looks good too. Neither A nor C appeals. They don't look all that bright.

shaysh87 · Answer

I really like the way the red head looks. she's very naturally pretty.

ElvenMr · Answer

B is the clear answer for me.

"Average height 27 year old brunette, who's only ever had one long term relationship, a bit shy a bit confident, likes to be active, athletic/slim , looks a lot younger/innocent "

RavVid · Answer

You have to love the background this girl chose. That won me. (Girls that was a joke in case you didn't get it).

Iron_Man · Answer

Average height 27 year old brunette, who's only ever had one long term relationship, a bit shy a bit confident, likes to be active, athletic/slim , looks a lot younger/innocent

exitseven · Answer

I pick A. She is different than anyone I ever dated so I would do it for the experience.

AimeeKyle · Answer

D first (closer to my age) and B second. I like that they are active and take care of themselves. The also are shy/introverted, so not into attention grabbing behavior.

SJ1984 · Answer

I like all of them. Can I select a combination of all four?

Fireguy17 · Answer

D, she is closer to my age.

John_Doesnt · Answer

Those pics are super fake with all the filters. I'd choose a real woman in the real world.

collie22 · Answer

I would ask them to tell me a joke before i could pick

Neilbud · Answer

I would have to get to know each one to decide. Looks and a resume are not enough for me

20yearsolder · Answer

I'm an older guy, I picked the last option.

Guy13 · Answer

Selection B and buy her some new teeth...

Guys, or girls who date girls, which girl would you choose?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said