Which art portrait of her looks best?

[MCheetah]

At some of you may already know, I've gotten a lot of artwork done of my late ex-fiancée and shown a little bit of it here on GAG, in her favorite color, purple. I've probably gotten like twenty of these done. Sometimes, the artist gets her just right. While other times, many things are off about her, such as her body shape, bust size, face, hair, etc.

Which portrait of her out of the ten pictures do you think looks best?

2018 Digital Portrait - VOTE H

Jolly Red Giant 2018 Portrait - VOTE I

Jolly Red Giant 2019 Portrait - VOTE J

2017 First Portrait

2019 Realistic Portrait

2020 More-accurate Realistic Portrait

2021 Digital Portrait

Spring 2022 Digital Portrait

Summer 2022 Digital Portrait

Fall 2022 Realistic Portrait

[Mia-Wallace]

A and C.

I like the coloring and lighting in those two. I'm sensitive to visuals and very saturated and luminous colors make me nauseous. In all other works saturation is just too high and the lighting is kind of off. And I know very luminous colors can be a part of a style, but it's not a style I would personally like.

And that one with the frog hands... 🤣

What I dislike about the rest:

H )

1. The coloring

2. That crappy background

I )

1. Face is off.

2. Lighting is terribly off.

3. Probably used some 3D assets or a template, but did a crappy job.

J )

1. The coloring. It's clean, but those greens and blues, that orange, and then the pink in her dress that's not repeated anywhere else just don't look professional together. Every single color that an artist adds to a canvas makes his work 10 times harder. If you want a very colorful work you got to work with a master.

B )

1. Coloring

2. Lighting on her face does not match her body.

D )

1. What's that weird orange light on her hair when she's inside? That's sunlight...

E )

1. Coloring

2. Hair

3. It looks like her boobs are melting, turning into a weird goo...

F )

1. Hands...

G )

1. Lighting. It's roo flat. Face is okay though.

[MCheetah]

Helpful art critiques. Thank you.

C is the most accurate one here regarding her actual body shape and proportions (with G coming a close second) and A and B being the most accurate for her face. She used to change her hairstyle like every single week or so, so she has no one "consistent" hairstyle, but A, F, or H is my favorite regarding her hairstyles.

H is the least accurate body (especially those small boobs when she was a 42J cup) and I is the least accurate face.

In the real photo for option D, she is in a museum, so I think the light behind her is supposed to be a wall light, with her head just blocking the light source and the light shining through her hair. But I'm unsure if the artist knew that or not, or if he did add "sunlight" to her, as you suggested.

My two favorites are C and G, cause they're the most accurate to how she actually looked, but no one seems to like G for some reason. I thought that'd be the favorite winner, here.

[Mia-Wallace]

Happy it helped. 🤙🏻

I like her face and hair in G. Her expression is nice. It's mostly the colors and lighting.

[Emiliamazing]

I really like the jolly red giant portraits from 2018 and 2019 :-)

[Emiliamazing]

The aerial lift is an adorable touch😊

[MCheetah]

Thank you.

[hahahmm]

2021 Digital Portrait -- feel like the head is too big or too small in a lot of the others

[MCheetah]

Thank you.

She was 6'3.5" tall and a 42J cup with wide hips, so honestly, the thing that annoys me the most is that the artists got her breasts or figure seriously wrong in a lot of the portraits. Her breasts or hips are way too small or narrow in some of the older portraits.

[TheUniqueOne96]

Spring 2022 Digital Portrait

[MCheetah]

Thanks.

[exitseven]

I voted for B. You can see the warmth behind her smile.

[sirderpsalot123]

I like the 3rd picture the best.

[MCheetah]

Thanks.

[bubblegunnn]

I love 4 and 6 tho

[MCheetah]

Thanks.

Do you mean fourth and sixth one total (A and C)? Or fourth and sixth ones on the poll (D and F)?

[JesseJayNeak]

First looks best

[Fuentes]

Not sure I can make up my mind