Guys, which makeup look is more attractive?

juliaaa
This one, which is more light and natural?

Guys, which makeup look is more attractive?


Or this one, which is smokey and much darker on the eyes?

Guys, which makeup look is more attractive?

I'm not asking about the attractiveness of these girls in general, but really their makeup look. Also guys, which do you find more attractive in general? The lighter, fresher look or the smokier, sexier look?

**By lighter and fresher I do not mean as light as just mascara and some blush. I mean like in the picture how she is wearing makeup but used natural colors.
First one, more natural
Second one, more sexy/smokey
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Guys, which makeup look is more attractive?
33 Opinion