Mirror Selfies or Actual Good Lighting “Photography”?

For PFP reasons, tinder reasons, maybe even other reasons...

Would it be considered too try hard to go for a real headshot/any real pic.. or should I just go take a mirror pfp/selfie
Selfie/mirror selfie
Headshot/other decent pic style
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Mirror Selfies or Actual Good Lighting “Photography”?
Post Opinion